Paul Craddick has now added a fourth part to the"Rethinking Iraq" series in which he's been reviewing diverse controversies - subjects of heated discussion especially over the Summer - associated with the war in Iraq. The latest entry concerns WMDs and the familiar arguments put forward by war opponents that the failure to turn up large WMD stockpiles exposes the entirety of the Bush Administration's case for war as false, even criminal. After examining the evidence, Paul reaches the following conclusion:
In light of the preponderance of informed opinion which before the war held that Iraq had not disarmed (entailing both infrastructure and extant weapons), and in light of the fact that infrastructural elements are now coming to light, it seems to me that it is still eminently reasonable to assume that Iraq did indeed have stockpiles of WMD which have so far eluded us – either through being hidden/moved, or destroyed. In any event, nothing yet has emerged – by a longshot – to establish that the war was/is fraudulent on its own terms.
Of course, many of us, including Paul, have argued further that there were multiple justifications for the war, of which the possible existence of deliverable WMDs in Iraq was merely the most frightening, but very few observers, it seems to me, have come up with reasonable responses to certain obvious questions. Paul's conclusions do not rest on any definitive answers to the WMD mysteries, but I have long thought (much of this post was in fact written several months ago) that the questions can be answered reasonably, even if we assume for sake of argument that the state of evidence never progresses far beyond what we currently possess.
1) If Saddam did not possess a WMD capability, why didn't he comply fully with UN inspections resolutions, and thus avoid war?
Even if Saddam had had all or most of his WMDs and WMD equipment destroyed, there are several reasons why he wouldn't want to comply with inspections: The aim of the inspections was not to discover hidden WMDs; the aim was to verify full disarmament or declare non-compliance with disarmament requirements. As Hans Blix himself confirmed, Iraq never offered more than isolated, piecemeal cooperation on matters of substance, and instead focused on stringing the inspectors along by offering superficial procedural cooperation.
Total cooperation would have required, among other things, full access to all elements of Iraq's WMD programs, including technicians and scientists, and all dual use equipment, alongside a full accounting. Saddam never came close to providing this. To do so would have exposed and confirmed his past deceptions - both known ones and new ones - and would have inevitably have added impetus to ever more intrusive and comprehensive efforts.
The end result would have been either real, complete disarmament, including the eradication of Saddam's ability ever to reconstitute the program, or confrontation. Saddam was unwilling to allow the former to occur, and instead hoped to delay and manage the latter - as he had successfully done in the past. Additionally, maintaining uncertainty about his WMD capacities served purposes of its own in managing external and internal threats, and refusing to give in on this (or virtually any) issue served his image as "the one who doesn't back down," which was fundamental to his political effectiveness and aspirations.
2) If Saddam possessed a WMD capability, why didn't he use it?
At no point did Saddam have any reason to believe that what WMD capacity he preserved would be of high military utility on the battlefield. WMDs of the type Saddam possessed even at the height of his military power are difficult to use effectively against a well-prepared, highly mobile force. Additionally, the moment that a single WMD was used, or even discovered in a position where it could be used, his political strategy - which became even more important once hostilities had actually begun - would have collapsed. (Even France had stated publically that WMD use would cause it to reverse its opposition to the war.)
Nor is there any reason to believe that this political strategy was ever abandoned, up to and including the US invasion, and even the present day. To us, Saddam's defeat seemed inevitable, but it may not have seemed that way to Saddam. Even at this late date, we have no reason to believe that Saddam has admitted defeat. Both he and the Iraqi people - including WMD scientists and WMD program officials - may still believe that a Baathist insurgency and other difficulties of occupation may sooner or later force a US withdrawal, and provide him (or his allies) with a chance to re-gain authority - if not over the entire country in the near term, then at least over a secure base of operations. He may even believe that he's re-gained momentum.
As for the WMDs themselves, I still tend to suspect that there are WMD materials and possibly even some real WMDs somewhere in Iraq, and that some items may have been successfully moved out of the country, but that the old WMD artillery shells and the like were probably destroyed or discarded, and that any quantities of precursor chem/bio materials are probably much smaller now than when originally observed by the UN. As has frequently been pointed out by David Kay and others, it's also worth keeping in mind that even x-thousand liters of one or another toxin requires only a few tens of barrels for storage, and that a much, much smaller amount is sufficient for re-starting the manufacturing process over again, especially if the "intellectual capacity" has been preserved.
Saddam knew this last point well. He was much smarter and more knowledgeable about and more experienced with WMDs - how they're made and how they're used militarily and politically - than, say, most Bush Administration opponents, and, it's fair to say, probably than a lot of Bush Administration operatives and allies as well.
, Viagra online, :-)), Generic viagra prices, cpt, Discount viagra online, %))), Viagra, %-P, Viagra online without a prescription, sowc, Order viagra, 468028, Viagra for sale, 865637, Buy levitra, ipd, Cialis, 98929,
Posted by: Online viagra | December 06, 2011 at 12:48 AM
, Cheap levitra, ocgah, Online viagra, 6469, Buy viagra, >:DDD, Buy viagra, byasq, Buy viagra online, 8O, Cialis online, njbeqa, Viagra online, =))), Viagra online cheap, 018, Generic viagra, =-D,
Posted by: Viagra online | December 08, 2011 at 01:00 AM
, Sildenafil online, >:-PP, Viagra, 972, Viagra, 8-(((, Discount viagra, :DDD, Viagra, >:P, Viagra, 8-PPP, Discount viagra, 06715, Viagra vs levitra, >:-P, Generic cialis, fvzxwd,
Posted by: Generic cialis | December 10, 2011 at 01:06 AM
, Viagra, 000076, Viagra online, vmo, Cialis online, =[[, Cheap levitra, >:-OOO, Cheap viagra, 8[[[, Generic viagra, 072655, Generic viagra, :-DD, Viagra online, ypqy, Viagra online without prescription, =-(,
Posted by: Order cialis | December 12, 2011 at 12:21 AM
, Cheap levitra, 651907, Viagra online, >:DD, Viagra price, 8-OO, Generic viagra, 208660, Generic viagra online, %(, Generic cialis, nrqgqe, Viagra, 3515, Viagra online pharmacy, pezdl, Generic viagra, uydomr,
Posted by: Viagra | December 12, 2011 at 12:26 AM
, Generic viagra online, uassn, Viagra, fejqr, Buy cialis, =-), Levitra online, :-((, Viagra, mld, Viagra side effects, :OO, Viagra, 4834, Viagra online, 1718, Viagra online without prescription, 24244,
Posted by: Cheap cialis | December 13, 2011 at 12:25 AM
, Order levitra, =((, Viagra online, vnsva, Viagra online, 6525, Buy viagra, 221080, Generic viagra online, 233538, Cialis online, lstgbs, Viagra, smlj, Online viagra, 8OO, Cheap viagra, 7071,
Posted by: Viagra | December 13, 2011 at 12:50 AM
, Sildenafil online, =], Generic viagra online, 939, Generic viagra, dvpjv, Cheap viagra, 671, Viagra, 795, Viagra, >:(, Viagra online without prescription, :-(((, Levitra online, cqtash, Cialis vs viagra, 290733,
Posted by: Viagra for sale | December 13, 2011 at 01:18 AM
, Cheap viagra online, 696031, Cheap viagra online, 99568, Viagra generic, >:-PPP, Viagra, :DD, Cialis online, :P, Viagra online without prescription, 078851, Generic viagra, qfwg, Generic viagra, :-P, Viagra, 813909,
Posted by: Cheap viagra | December 13, 2011 at 01:20 AM
, Generic levitra, gqmjha, Viagra online, 140, Generic viagra, rzbl, Generic viagra, 944, Viagra, 539, Generic cialis, =)), Viagra, 653145, Discount viagra online, 9192, Generic viagra, 75007,
Posted by: Viagra | December 16, 2011 at 12:13 AM
, Viagra online, >:], Sildenafil, 225071, Viagra, uufx, Viagra, uhd, Buy viagra, ipo, Discount viagra, qzud, Viagra, dzo, Cialis, 5107, Cheap cialis, yrn,
Posted by: Viagra | December 16, 2011 at 12:15 AM
, Viagra online, mauc, Cheap viagra online, 43841, Cialis online without prescription, >:-PP, Generic levitra, >:-PPP, Generic viagra online, 848, Generic viagra online, =), Order viagra, wqpgjx, Viagra online, 1734, Cialis vs viagra, >:D,
Posted by: Viagra online 100mg | December 16, 2011 at 01:08 AM
, Viagra, uxen, Discount viagra, :-OO, Generic viagra, >:-]]], Viagra for sale, %-((, Buy viagra online, 9714, Viagra online, sjwghe, Cheap viagra, mvqwzn, Cialis, thbmle, Cialis online, 585,
Posted by: Sildenafil | December 18, 2011 at 12:23 AM
, Viagra online, =]]], Viagra, 3837, Cialis online, =-PPP, Levitra online, =PP, Generic viagra, >:[[, Generic viagra, =))), Viagra price, 8216, Online viagra, 90359, Viagra, 140,
Posted by: Levitra online | December 22, 2011 at 12:52 AM
, Levitra, gjwgk, Viagra, >:-DDD, Sildenafil, qzuj, Viagra online without prescription, 958589, Buy viagra online, ajv, Online viagra, 8OO, Cialis online without prescription, 91913, Discount viagra online, hwybj, Viagra, :-OOO,
Posted by: Sildenafil | December 22, 2011 at 01:20 AM
, Viagra online without prescription, 41860, Generic viagra online, =-))), Discount viagra online, :OOO, Viagra for sale, 34663, Buy viagra without prescription, >:-OOO, Buy viagra, qlw, Viagra, xddsb, Viagra vs levitra, zjugg, Cialis online without prescription, abobc,
Posted by: Viagra online | December 23, 2011 at 12:18 AM
, Viagra price, ueslbq, Viagra online, 91196, Cialis online, =(, Levitra, %-], Discount viagra, =-O, Generic viagra, >:DDD, Cialis vs viagra, mjepkm, Online viagra, ned, Viagra, :[,
Posted by: Order viagra | December 23, 2011 at 01:01 AM
, Levitra, =-(, Generic viagra online, novt, Viagra online without prescription, 7867, Viagra online without prescription, =]], Generic viagra, bup, Cialis, 2795, Online viagra, dxwlt, Cheap viagra, 3121, Buy viagra, %OO,
Posted by: Cheap viagra | December 23, 2011 at 01:21 AM
, Viagra online without prescription, 847199, Generic viagra online, =O, Viagra sales, 8-[[, Discount viagra, lvzj, Viagra, 842857, Viagra online, 01753, Buy viagra, usbm, Levitra, :P, Cialis vs viagra, rej,
Posted by: Viagra | December 23, 2011 at 01:21 AM
, Viagra, %-OO, Viagra online, dkfx, Cheap cialis, =-))), Levitra generic, ildl, Cheap viagra, 9661, Viagra, >:]], Generic viagra, 8]]], Viagra online, rijmi, Viagra price, %-PP,
Posted by: Viagra online without prescription | December 25, 2011 at 12:11 AM
, Sildenafil online, 501, Generic viagra online, pci, Viagra sales, %P, Cheap viagra online, =((, Viagra, :-OOO, Discount viagra, kyddy, Buy viagra online, 8446, Cialis, 9543, Cialis online, %-(,
Posted by: Cheap cialis | December 25, 2011 at 12:25 AM
, Viagra online 100mg, 757472, Cialis vs viagra, %-PPP, Cialis, 4164, Levitra online, 074, Viagra online pharmacy, :(((, Buy viagra online, 0628, Viagra generic fast, gaspko, Viagra online, 739, Cialis vs viagra, 4667,
Posted by: Levitra online | December 25, 2011 at 01:13 AM
, Generic viagra online, bzuzfm, Viagra, qyw, Order cialis, hnrkzr, Levitra generic, 8-O, Generic viagra, rbmzlp, Viagra generic fast, 1980, Viagra price, lhorb, Viagra online, borwf, Discount viagra, %-PPP,
Posted by: Discount viagra online | December 26, 2011 at 12:16 AM
, Levitra online without prescription, %-O, Viagra online, kfo, Viagra price, %-((, Buy viagra online, 934995, Generic viagra online, 998, Cialis online, :-[[, Viagra online, 1911, Generic viagra online, 8-DD, Cheap viagra, >:DDD,
Posted by: Levitra | December 26, 2011 at 12:41 AM
, Viagra, afhecl, Viagra, kis, Viagra, 517, Viagra, fwq, Cialis online pharmacy, =-], Sildenafil, 5634, Viagra, =O, Cheap viagra, >:[[[, Online viagra, 8OO,
Posted by: Discount viagra | December 26, 2011 at 12:42 AM